Assessment Overview
Reproduce the Heider & Simmel (1944) animation in After Effects, then use it as the basis for a reflective blog, guide script and screen-share video exploring why simple shapes in motion read as emotion and intention.

Blog
“The below reflective blog will explore the findings of psychological theory to understand why simple geometric motion reads as emotion and intention.”
Join the Discussion
First Contact
"Your immediate, untheorized response to the animation."

(Kenjirou, 2010)
When watching the Heider and Simmel experiment for the first time, I unfortunately had already watched the first lecture and completed the readings. So, upon watching this experiment I found myself fighting my responses to the animation sequence. I felt I was seeing what everyone talked about and fought to reject those ideas. This then led to an objective viewing of the sequence, losing the ability to have an unfiltered response.
I then concluded that this sequence has multiple potential story lines depending on what the viewers wants to see or even their current mood. From kids’ playing then being disciplined, to a larger animal protecting its den unsuccessfully or the larger object attacking the smaller objects.
What I did notice is that the movements of each object are the fundamentals that drive the narratives created. From the small circles fast side to side movements suggesting anxiety or fear, to the slower side to side motion of the triangles, suggesting disagreements between the objects. Giving us an animation experiment where the story is dependent on the viewer.
Building It
"The process and choices behind your After Effects reproduction."

Being a 3D design and animation student, I approached my development of this sequence in aftereffects using pose to pose. Taking the sequence, setting the key frames & finishing up with refining.
I then looked closely to determine the animation techniques I could see to enhance the final sequence. When looking at the experiment I decided slow in and out, timing and staging can be seen. I also felt that by implementing other animation techniques like squash and stretch would create the potential to lose the ambiguity of the sequence. This would then drive the audience towards a set narrative rather than the open-ended narrative seen. This would counter the experiment & is why any further techniques were excluded.
(Sourced through Google Images)

Why We See a Story
"Close analysis of which specific choices create particular impressions."
When looking at the Heider and Simmel experiment, there are a handful of choices seen that I believe drive people’s impressions. The first being the use of grouping through the size of the objects & their positions.
Having two smaller objects and the third larger object you see the application of the principle of similarity. According to research, (Lidwell et al., 2010, p. 226) the Gestalt principle of similarity asserts that elements that are seen to be similar are then perceived as a single group. With Riley (2024), stating that human brains constantly make predictions of objects in our environment to chunk objects and ultimately conserve energy. Giving this experiment its first impression within the first six seconds. Ultimately creating a divide between the objects on screen.
This is then bolstered with the principal proximity. According to Lidwell et al. (2010), elements that are close together are also perceived as a single group and are then also interpreted to be related. With Lidwell et al. (2026) stating that proximity is one of the most powerful means of indicating relatedness in design & will generally overwhelm competing visual cues. Opening the door to various impressions and interpretations of the relationship between the two groups of shapes.
The movement of the objects across Heider and Simmel’s experiment is another way in which impressions are made. Across the duration of the animation sequence sharp, fast & pointed movements are often observed between the larger object and one smaller object. This opens the door to impressions of anger, anxiety, fear or conflict. The smooth, circular movements seen contrast with these sharper movements. Opening the door to impressions of joy, fun, nervousness or calm.
These impressions are interpreted through the human process of anthropomorphism & semiotics. Anthropomorphising is defined as the human process of attributing human qualities to objects or animals (Barkley, 2022). Semiotics on the other hand is the study of signs and symbols & helps us to understand how these elements can intern express ideas, emotions and messages through visual art forms (Reynolds, 2023).


(Lidwell et al.,2010)
(Lidwell et al.,2010)
(Una, n.d.)

The Psychology Behind It
"Application of at least two psychological theories."

(Practical Psychology, 2021)
When thinking back to the narratives created when watching the Heider & Simmel experiment and the impressions generated. It could be suggested that attribution theory can be found through the responses given. More specifically, external attributions.
External attributions are detailed as the process of assigning the cause of behaviour to the situation outside of the person or in this case shapes control (Mcleod, 2023). This is evident as the narrative generated in week’s one lecture was that the large triangle attacked the smaller objects. Giving us a narrative based on the movements of the objects. Attributing all narrative to the external factors rather than personality traits.
This is also supported through the Covariation model. This model is a comprehensive look at how we assign causality to behaviour(Mcleod, 2023). With conclusions developed through systematic evaluations of information based on consensus, distinctiveness & consistency (Mcleod, 2023).
In the case of the Heider and Simmel experiment, the consensus is high as most of the shapes move in the same manner towards the larger triangle. In addition to this the consistency is also high as the frequency we attribute aggressive/ fast movements towards the smaller objects is present consistently across all interactions between these objects. It is stated that when the evaluations show high causality & high consistency then the resulting evaluation will lead humans to contribute behaviours to external factors (Practical Psychology, 2021).
Where Perception Diverges
"Comparison of your interpretation with a classmate’s."

Comparing my interpretation of the Heider & Simmel experiment and my classmates I worked with both Tammy Roche’s interpretation posted & the class discussions. I absolutely loved Tammy’s interpretation, seeing all the objects in the experiment as one collective object was fascinating.
What I found to be even more fascinating, was that no matter how many times I watched the clip again I couldn’t see the jug. I could see the potential, with the smaller objects moving around being the water but my brain didn’t see it.
When thinking back to week one’s lecture however I could see the story discussed, where the larger triangle was attacking the smaller objects. As discussed previously this view took over my own interpretation which then drove me to create different stories.
In the end I couldn’t tell you what my true interpretation was, but I was happy to be able to question my response as I found it rewarding to see all the different stories I could then apply to the sequence.
Reflection
"What the process revealed about your own perception."
On reflection of the Heider and Simmel experiment and people’s opinions of the experiment I am in two minds. The fact that stories are automatically applied to inanimate objects through to how eyes process information is truly fascinating and undeniable. The fact that this process is automatic yet could be influenced is also extremely fascinating.
Which leads me to understand that this research is truly complex. But I believe that our understanding is likely to have barely scratched the surface.
I say this as I find myself to be sceptical due to the lack of data present within the research for the gestalt theories. When looking at those included in the experiment I saw that only the three men who published the theories were included as that was just how things were done back then (Wagemans et al., 2012, p. 1173). With the lack of variety & numbers of test subjects outside of three men left me angry & questioning our understanding.
As the research process proves to yet again dismisses females or anyone who is slightly different to a white middle-aged male & I dare say this would be present across most of the other older theories. I would love to see the work conducted again to see how the theories would evolve.
Imagine how much depth it would create if we included the minds of people like Temple Grandin or Albert Einstein, who are said to be autistic. It could truly take design to a new level if we take the time to see the world through all the different eyes of the world.
Let’s face it, we wouldn’t have evolved so successfully if we all saw things the same way.
