top of page

Reflection

Kelsey Elliott
Oct 11
2 min read

On reflection of the Heider and Simmel experiment and people’s opinions of the experiment I am in two minds. The fact that stories are automatically applied to inanimate objects through to how eyes process information is truly fascinating and undeniable. The fact that this process is automatic yet could be influenced is also extremely fascinating.


Which leads me to understand that this research is truly complex. But I believe that our understanding is likely to have barely scratched the surface.


I say this as I find myself to be sceptical due to the lack of data present within the research for the gestalt theories. When looking at those included in the experiment I saw that only the three men who published the theories were included as that was just how things were done back then (Wagemans et al., 2012, p. 1173).


With the lack of variety & numbers of test subjects outside of three men left me angry & questioning our understanding. As the research process proves to yet again dismisses females or anyone who is slightly different to a white middle-aged male & I dare say this would be present across most of the other older theories.


I would love to see the work conducted again to see how the theories would evolve. Imagine how much depth it would create if we included the minds of people like Temple Grandin or Albert Einstein, who are said to be autistic.


It could truly take design to a new level if we take the time to see the world through all the different eyes of the world.


Let’s face it, we wouldn’t have evolved so successfully if we all saw things the same way.   

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Where Perception Diverges

Comparing my interpretation of the Heider & Simmel experiment and my classmates I worked with both Tammy Roche’s interpretation posted & the class discussions. I absolutely loved Tammy’s interpretatio

 
 
 
The Psychology Behind It

When thinking back to the narratives created when watching the Heider & Simmel experiment and the impressions generated. It could be suggested that attribution theory can be found through the response

 
 
 
First Contact

When watching the Heider and Simmel experiment for the first time, I unfortunately had already watched the first lecture and completed the readings. So, upon watching this experiment I found myself fi

 
 

Comments


bottom of page